Friday, June 09, 2006

The Black Yesterday!

Yesterday's most remarkable news was with no doubt the assassination of Abu Musab Al-Zarqawi in Iraq. I am not going to put my own views about the guy, whether bashing or praising, as I believe we only have half of the story, that is of course if we do have a true half first of all. What concerned me rather were the reaction of us as Jordanians, both the people and the government. I think Jad's post "Do we really need a better reason to celebrate than this one? I don't think so" symbolises very accurately the majority of Jordanian bloggers' reactions toward the incident while Naseem went through many of these reactions and summarised them in this latest post. Reading many of those posts I came out with the very dangerous and scary conclusion that whoever wrote the posts had serious rancor and animosity deep in their hearts. I cannot believe that any of us can give the chance for all that hatred to penetrate their faith, their soul and their humanity and find its way to their heart. I have two messages here, the first is for those who were directly affected by the terrorist attacks in Amman a couple of months ago; May Allah accept those you lost in the heaven. If these attacks are to add to you something it should be strength, solidity, and determination that your lives shall continue fearlessly no matter of the obstacles some cowards are throwing in your way. It is via positive feeling and thinking that you can add positively to your life and to the lives of those surrounding you. Do not give the evil-minded the joy of satisfaction that they succeeded to implant bad blood into your body. My second message is for all my Jordanian brothers and sisters; and that is what applies to me in regard to the lack of the full story does in deed apply to you. I wasn't in Jordan when Amman's attacks took place, so I had an exceptional advantage of watching, reading and analyzing the event and its consequences from the top of the ivory tower, yet I can tell you that for me there are still many gaps and holes that need to be filled before I can understand what actually happened and before I can make my ownjudgmentt on who actually committed the crime. Linking this to those who lived the event in Jordan I am certain that most of their knowledge about the event came from the local media or from spoken rumors or fish stories. And I'm not blaming anyone here but rather stating the fact that people in such circumstancess usually tend to lose their temper and therefore can accept any piece of information that they receivewithouth the need to dig deeper to examine its truth or falsehood. Hence we should refrain ourselves fromadoptingg stories or scenarios that have cuttings or ambiguity somewhere even if we have full trust in their resources, as those resources may themselves be unaware of the deficiencies in their narrated stories. The reaction of the government exceeded even the worst of expectations; the detention of Aljazeera's correspondent Yasser Abu Hilala live on TV while he was interviewing one of Al-Zarqawi's relatives would ruin any claimed reputation for Jordan in the field of human rights and freedom of speech and press. I always condemned and rallied against the Israeli and American violations of human rights covenants and other agreements protecting journalists and against the attacks on Journalists in the hot spots of the world, including Palestine, Iraq, Lebanon, Philippines and Columbia, but even in these places security forces have always made sure that their crimes are completely hidden away from the eyes of Journalism. It is the first time in my life to hear that the intelligence officers dared to arrest a journalist live on front of the camera while doing his normal legal work and unashamed of the millions watching it. This should be considered very seriously and I am afraid the Jordanian government will need to work very hard to gain the forgiveness of human rights protectors and activists among Jordanians and around the world. Questioning the officers responsible for that shameful detention and making them accountable for it should be thethee first but not the only effort in that directionn.

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

Jordan understands how the US works and behaves the same. It knows that arresting a journalist on live TV is going to anger Jordanians, Americans and the rest of the world. But it also knows that people will soon forget about this and go on with their daily lives.

When the US announced its war in Iraq, the world has witnessed the largest demosnstrations in history. It was an amazing sight, that of hope.

And then nothing. And this is how things will be, nothing.

Seriously, what are these "human rights" groups going to do? Attack Jordan?!

Jad said...

Hey,
I'm not sure how someone would dig more for more information or for the other view of the story when there are dead innocent people because of him.


I'm with questioning everything even faith and believe at least to make it stronger but in Amman attack or the Black Wednesday there is no room for questioning as it wasn't a complex equation.

Jabal said...

Regarding the comment on the US lesson, I don't care about USA whether it likes what we do or it doesn't. It is all about us as Jordanians, we need to care about this because it is our lives and our rights that we are talking about. This is our country and we want to make sure that everyone can practise their freedoms specially when they don't break the law. Freedom of speech and opinion is one fundamental freedom that we should struggle to save, as one country means nothing without its people and thus a free Jordan means free fearless Jordanians in the first place.

Jabal said...

Thanks Jad for your comment. I can understand that the world is so complex that the majority of people prefer to take things they see or hear for granted with making the very basic assumption that the truth is not necessarily what always receive the first. Reflecting this on the Black Wednesday terrorist attacks, there are still three open possible scenarios (non of which was convincing enough to be the ultimately right one). The 1st is that Al-Zarqawi was the one responsible for the attacks; the second is that it is all made up by the Americans to spoil Al-Zarqawi's name in his own a country, as well as in Iraq, to win the media battle in their long-running war with Mujahedeen (assuming that Al-Zarqawi and his men's hand are clear from the blood of innocent Iraqis). The third scenario is that our government needed to unveil the investigation results as quickly as possible to keep Jordanians confident in their security system, therefore was pushed to wrongly charge Al-Qaeda for the massacre. I know I may sound hypocritical to consider the last scenario but I have my good reasons to keep the door open on all three possibilities. I think I will follow up the issue soon with another article to clarify these reasons.

Jad said...

Jabal,
Al-azarkawi's name already spoiled since they called him Zarkawi not his real name and family name which the last is one of the biggest families in Jordan, nevertheless the second scenario is out of logic as al-zarkawi himself adapted that attack in a recorded tape and it was published on almost all news channels also his name was already spoiled because of his previous attacks the one against GID and the Aqaba one which he adapted both and defended both in recorded tape.

However I think unveil investigation results has less disadvantages than the advantages.

I'll be waiting for your next article dude :-)

Jabal said...

Ok Jad, I'm sure this is an endless discussion; but what you answered is exactly what I meant. A recorded tape! Have you seen the guy? Have you ever visited an FM radio stadio where you can modify voices as you wish? I'm not saying that this is what happened, but rather advising you not to take what you receive for granted. I do appreciate that thinking of the world around us to be such wild can drive us crazy but unfortunately this is life. I'm not a fan of the literal consiperacy theory but intelligence systems are getting dirtier and dirtier everyday. Have you ever watch or read about the new theories of what actually happened in September 11 attacks in NY and Pentagon?

Yet I want to stress on the stupidity of some MPs' reactions to the killing of Zarqawi. As this is vague and contraversial issue, they should not visit Al-Zarqawi House to pay condolences as they didn't know him in person, and if they were desperate to then there was no need for their afterwards statements praising the man and insulting the bombings victims by refusing to call them martyrs. The government took the other extreme by refusing to bury Abu-Musab's body in his birthplace city and closing his solace house (according to news reports). This is insensible as Abu Musab is now dead and the burying and the consolation are religious duties to relieve the pain of his family. At the end they are humans and they don't have to suffer for others' sins (this is ofcourse assuming that Abu Musab was behind any attacks that led to the killing of innocents in Jordan or Iraq)

I hope this makes more sense now, and thanks again for your comments Jad :)

Romd said...

Dear Akram,
You know that I am not a big fan of the Jordanian government or of the Jordanian policy towards almost everything. Yet for the simple fact of being neutral and just, I can't take the opposition side of everything the government has to say.

I don't believe a lot of the official story the government has to offer. I've heard personal stories from trusted and involved people that flip some official statement upside down. Yet again... there could be some truth in what the government has to say.

Is Abu Mos3ab a terrorist or a martyr??? To be honest I don't know. Is he just something the government and its biggest ally the US to put the blame on??? Maybe.

The point Akram is like what you have said: You've been setting over a tower watching what is going on around, and you should have seen by now that what is happening is not in the hand of a couple of people like Al-Zarqawi or Bin-Laden, it is something much more big and the idea of blaming a couple of figures for it is simply stupid and misleading, it is just the governmental need to provide the mob with the answers, the simpler, the better.

Now, about what happened with some of Muslim brothers who praised Al-Zarqawi. If you come to the abstract of things: they broke no law, and by law, the government has no right to detain any of them and treat them like that.

Yet, I don't agree with their actions. As I don't agree to the visit of the Israeli PM to Jordan and the death of many Palestinian kids just days after wards (and even today).

G.W.Bosh praised someone like Sharon as a man of peace; I wish we could detain him on his next visit to Jordan (passing to Iraq, most probably).

 

Free Palestine, refugees, blog, blogger, wordpress, against the war, peace, solidarity, quiz, palestinians, films, documentaries, free stuff, iphone, free calls, free